In mystery stories, readers are drawn into thrilling tales of deception, clues and suspense. A clever technique used by skilled mystery writers is the “red herring”. This literary device misleads the reader, distracting them from the real clues and the real culprit. It adds surprise and suspense to the story. As readers delve into the stories, they encounter well-crafted red herrings that keep them guessing until the final reveal.
Photo by Kat Canavan on Unsplash
Agatha Christie, often referred to as the “Queen of Mystery”, was a master at using red herrings in her classic detective novels. One such example can be found in her iconic novel, “Murder on the Orient Express”. As the brilliant detective Hercule Poirot investigates the murder of Mr Ratchett on the luxurious train, numerous suspects with plausible motives emerge. Christie greatly weaves a complex web of clues and conflicting testimony, leading the reader to suspect various characters. Passengers’ secrets, past connections and conflicting alibis create a maze of deception, making it difficult for the reader to discern the real murderer. But when Poirot reveals the solution, readers are astonished to discover that the evidence has been skillfully manipulated to deceive them, leaving the real culprit hidden among the tangled threads of the red herring.
Similarly, the works of Sir Arthur Conan Doyle, featuring the brilliant detective Sherlock Holmes, demonstrate the ingenious use of red herrings. In “The Hound of the Baskervilles”, Holmes and his faithful companion Dr Watson are tasked with solving the mystery of a family curse and a deadly ghostly hound. Throughout the investigation, a number of suspects, including the mysterious Barrymores and the intimidating Stapleton, seem to be shrouded in suspicion. Doyle cleverly intersperses misleading details and false leads, tantalising the reader with multiple possible solutions. As the duo solve the case, the real culprit remains hidden among the distractions, leaving the reader in for a surprise discovery.
Red herrings are not limited to classic novels; they are a common element in other forms of detective fiction, including television shows. The popular cartoon series “Scooby-Doo” is a perfect example. In each episode, the gang of Mystery Inc. sets out to solve various mysteries involving ghosts, monsters and criminals. The narrative often introduces numerous suspects with suspicious motives and behaviour, leading viewers on a wild chase to find the truth. In the end, however, the real culprit is usually revealed to be someone completely unexpected, cleverly hidden among the red herrings scattered throughout the story.
Red herrings are an essential part of classic detective fiction, building suspense and challenging readers and viewers to deduce the truth. Writers and creators toy with their audience’s expectations, creating an exciting journey that leads them astray, only to find the satisfying conclusion at the end. The deceptive nature of red herrings ensures that mystery lovers remain captivated by the art of detection (and deception), constantly searching for the truth amidst the maze of clues and misdirection.
Since “Red Herring” is a “plot” method of narrative techniques (or literary devices), other methods in these articles might interest you:
Comentarios